Skip to Content

C.O Bigelow Rose Salve vs. Smith’s Rosebud Salve

C.O Bigelow Rose Salve vs. Smith’s Rosebud Salve

Since time memorial salves have been essential products in skincare maintenance. These products contain vital ingredients that help them perform multifunctional roles on the skin, such as easing irritation, dryness, and healing eczema, minor burns, and chapped lips. 

Salves are basically ointment-based moisturizers that, upon application, penetrate deep into the skin, healing it and moisturizing it. C.O Bigelow Rose Salve vs. Smith’s Rosebud salve is two salves that have been around since the 1800s. These two skincare products are more similar than they are different. 

They are both rose-scented salves that help smoothen and condition your skin and lips. These two salves also contain petrolatum as their main active ingredient. 

As you can already tell, choosing between these two products is not easy. For starters, they both perform multipurpose functions in the body. So, which one of the two is best for you? Read on to find out. 

C.O Bigelow Rose Salve

C.O Bigelow rose salve is a multipurpose salve developed by Bigelow Chemists. It has been around since the 1800s, and it can be used on a wide range of skin conditions, including healing chapped lips, cuticles, and dry patches on the face, elbows, and knees. This cruelty-free salve contains a rose extract that aids in easing irritation, conditioning the skin, and healing chapped lips and dry skin patches on either the face or the body. 

The rose and lavender oils contained in this salve help ease inflammation and redness from irritated skin. Bigelow rose salve also contains a petrolatum ingredient that helps in locking in moisture to prevent dryness and irritation. 

Bigelow rose salve does not leave any waxy residue or slippery feeling. The pinkish-red, odorless, and clear salve is medium spreading and will sink into your skin easily after application. 

Bigelow Company has been manufacturing men and women skincare products for over 160 years. This company is known to use natural ingredients in all its products, and it does not test on animals. Despite transferring ownership to the Bath & Body Works brand in the recent past, products from Bigelow are still safe, natural, and cruelty-free. As such, you can rest assured that this salve will perform to its expectations without irritating your skin or lips. 

C.O Bigelow Rose Salve vs. Smith's Rosebud Salve

C.O Bigelow Rose Salve

Ingredients Contained In C.O Bigelow Rose Salve

C.O Bigelow Rose Salve contains the following ingredients, petrolatum, lanolin Oil, Squalene, Flavor (Aroma), Octyldodecanol, Gossypium Herbaceum (Cotton) Seed Oil, Rosa Canina Fruit Extract, Bisabolol, Jojoba Esters, Red 30 Lake (CI73360). 

Smith’s Rosebud Salve

Smith’s rosebud salve is a versatile product that can be used as a lip balm or gloss, makeup remover, cuticle cream, dry skin moisturizer, highlighter, diaper rash, or eczema treatment. This non-waxy and non-sticky salve contain natural ingredients making it safe for anyone worried about allergy from synthetic products. 

C.O Bigelow Rose Salve vs. Smith's Rosebud Salve

Smith’s Rosebud Salve

Manufactured by Smith’s Rosebud Perfume Co., this salve is petroleum-free and will thus not break you out. This salve is pink in color, and it contains a rose-scented smell. It does not leave any residue or stickiness upon application. 

Ingredients Contained in Smith’s Rosebud Salve

This salve contains three ingredients as follows; petrolatum, which acts as an emollient, moisturizer and skin protector, cottonseed oil which helps in skin conditioning and fragrance. 

How To Use C.O Bigelow Rose Salve Vs. Smith’s Rosebud Salve

The primary thing to note when using these two salves is that a little dab of the product goes a long way. Regardless of what you are using the salves for, always ensure to work with a small amount for good results. 

To open the tin, tilt it slowly as you pull the top part up. It will take some practice and patience to learn the tricks of opening these salves’ packaging tins, but once you grasp the idea, you will be good to go. Once the tin is opened, get a pea-sized amount of the salve and apply it to your affected area gently. 

You can apply the salves as many times a day as you would love to depend on your condition and preference. As always, ensure to work with a small amount and close the tin after every use to avoid bacteria contaminating the product. 

Differences between C.O Bigelow Rose Salve and Smith’s Rosebud Salve

Although these two salves contain natural ingredients and serve almost the same purpose, they are different in some ways, as discussed below. 

The primary difference between these two products is the color. Bigelow Rose Salve contains a red, pinkish color that’s somewhat shouting, while Smith’s rosebud salve has a cooler pink tone. Another difference is in the scent. 

Bigelow rose salve contains a soft rose smell, while smith rosebud salve smells more like roses and has a stronger rose scent. Bigelow salve is also runnier than Smith’s rosebud salve.  

C.O Bigelow Rose Salve vs. Smith’s Rosebud Salve: Which One Is Better For You?

These two products work the same way to moisturize and condition your lips and skin. The right one for you will depend on your budget and preference. Bigelow rose salve currently retails at $7.50, while Smith’s rosebud salve goes for $6.45. 

It’s also worth noting that these two products have excellent packaging that’s appealing to the eye, portable, and sturdy. Take note, however, that some customers on Amazon and other online selling platforms have expressed difficulty with opening the Bigelow Rose Salve tin. 

This product also seems a bit runnier than the Smith’s rosebud salve and may be perfect for your eyebrows, feet, and elbow area application. Both of these products will also dissolve into your skin without leaving any residue or stickiness. 

It’s also important to note that Bigelow Rose salve contains more ingredients than Smith’s rosebud salve. As such, Bigelow Rose salve will have other added advantages to your body than Smith’s salve. 


C.O Bigelow Rose Salve vs. Smith’s Rosebud salve will work perfectly in conditioning and moisturizing your skin to help get rid of chapped lips, dry feet, cuticles, irritation, minor burns, and diaper rash. For best results, always ensure to apply a small amount of the product as many times a day as you would desire. 

Also, keep up with your regular skincare routine, such as frequent cleansing and exfoliating with gentle and non-comedogenic products.